Only a sith deals in absolutes meaning

Discussion in ' Literature ' started by masterskywalkerApr 8, Log in or Sign up. Jedi Council Forums. Or, how to make sense of nonsense Discussion in ' Literature ' started by masterskywalkerApr 8,

The relationship -- and eventual conflict -- between Anakin Skywalker and Obi-Wan Kenobi is one of the most fundamental parts of the Star Wars saga. It comes with a number of memorable moments, as well as notable dialogue in both the best and worst ways. It's a uniformly strange line, not only for the confusion it elicits but for its sheer clunkiness. Nevertheless, Ewan McGregor sold it with his delivery, and its arrival before one of the most anticipated duels in the franchise's history makes it stand out. It's arguably the most confounding line in the series, as the statement itself is an absolute. Yet, the line has become a staple among the Star Wars faithful and even turned into a meme.

Only a sith deals in absolutes meaning

.

Jedi BenApr 9,

.

The world of Star Wars is full of different memorable quotes coming from some of the most memorable characters in the best scenes possible. Obi-Wan Kenobi told Anakin Skywalker this when the latter branded him as an enemy for disagreeing with him. Many Star Wars fans have misinterpreted this quote from Obi-Wan to be an absolute statement concerning how the Jedi and the Sith look at different situations. So, with that said, we are here to look at what this quote from Obi-Wan Kenobi means and why it is so meaningful. In that regard, he went to the dark side of the Force and helped Palpatine out in carrying Order 66 when he went to the Jedi Temple to slaughter the Jedi that there were there, including the innocent younglings. When Jedi Masters Yoda and Obi-Wan Kenobi snuck back into the Jedi Temple to look at the security footage of what happened, they were shocked to discover that Anakin had fallen to the dark side when he killed the people in the Jedi Temple and was seen kneeling down in reverence and respect to Palpatine, who had become his new master. As such, Yoda sent Obi-Wan to kill Anakin while he went to Palpatine in an attempt to assassinate the newly crowned emperor. Of course, Obi-Wan Kenobi could never agree with what Anakin had done because he did horrible and evil things for the sake of his twisted sense of security, justice, and peace in the galaxy.

Only a sith deals in absolutes meaning

Close your eyes, and play your favorite movie quote in your head. Now, imagine that same quote, only Obi-Wan Kenobi is saying it and you can choose whichever Obi-Wan actor you'd like, they all work perfectly fine. See how much better it is? But Obi-Wan's wry, playful tone is good for much more than enhancing the words of others -- that crazy old wizard has plenty of wisdom of his own. Here's a look at some of the wisdom that defined one of our favorite Jedi Masters:. Philosophical and moral principles are not laws of nature. Like John Locke the philosopher, not the LOST character said, we're born tabula rasas -- blank slates that, in time, will form a perspective all our own.

Trampoline park greenwood

Obi-Wan is not only calling out Anakin's twisted beliefs i. Condemning absolutes in absolute terms turns it into a paradox, but more to the point, it avoids the uncomfortable truth that the Jedi can be just as rigid and black-and-white as the Sith. Registered: Nov 25, It's a uniformly strange line, not only for the confusion it elicits but for its sheer clunkiness. He made his 'you're either with us or with the terrorists" assertion sometime before the movie came out. Ghost , Apr 9, No, create an account now. Show Ignored Content. Obi-Wan is simply observing the change in Anakin's behavior. Also, his statement isn't so much "nonsense" as it is paradoxical. On the subject of Jedi absolutism: The only thing they get dogmatic about is the darkside, but even using that term doesn't feel right; it is like calling a nuclear technician dogmatic because he demands you follow all the safety protocols. I think Obi wan was just trying to say "obviously you're sith because you're talking nonsense" as opposed to "factoid 1 about the sith is They often speak in absolutes themselves, such as Yoda's famous line, "Do or do not. NelanisGhost , Apr 8, In the most general teams, it's an accurate assessment and lets the film advance to the fight without muddying Obi-Wan's judgment.

The relationship -- and eventual conflict -- between Anakin Skywalker and Obi-Wan Kenobi is one of the most fundamental parts of the Star Wars saga. It comes with a number of memorable moments, as well as notable dialogue in both the best and worst ways. It's a uniformly strange line, not only for the confusion it elicits but for its sheer clunkiness.

I don't think Obi-Wan's statement is innacurate or ambiguous so much as it is hypocritical. The strongest example occurs in the Obi-Wan Kenobi miniseries , as he witnesses the redemption of Reva Sevander, which disproves the idea that the Sith are irredeemable. Obi Wan is actually right to point it out. MasterKenobi , Apr 9, The flaw in Obi-Wan's thinking starts with semantics. Mostly, it's a testament to a singularly odd line in a franchise that everyone knows extremely well. Shadojoker , Apr 8, I don't think he was very stable at that moment, but it was stupid. It probably does, a little bit. Also, his statement isn't so much "nonsense" as it is paradoxical. A flaw more and more common among Jedi.